Today we are looking at how to properly paint orange peel texture in Flying Horse homes without making it look worse or peeling early. At Simplify Painting, we provide professional residential interior and exterior painting services to homeowners across Colorado Springs, including Flying Horse, Pinon Valley, and Stetson Ranch.
If you’re standing in your great room looking at that bumpy, speckled orange peel texture on a 20-foot wall and wondering if you can just roll paint on it like a flat wall, you’re asking the right question before making a mistake we see often in this neighborhood.
Can you paint over orange peel texture like a flat wall?
No. Orange peel texture absorbs and reflects paint differently than flat drywall, and that matters more in Flying Horse because of the scale of these walls. Roll a tall great room wall the way you’d roll a flat bedroom wall and you’ll get uneven sheen, roller lines stuck in the texture dips, or thin spots, all of which show up under the large windows these homes are built around.
Why is orange peel so common in Flying Horse homes?
Most homes here were built from the mid-2000s on by custom builders who used orange peel as the standard finish because it’s faster to apply than a smooth Level 5 finish and hides minor drywall seams. It shows up most on the long great room walls, stairwells, and two-story foyers that define many Flying Horse floor plans.
That same speed is why these walls are tricky to repaint years later. The bumps are small, so mistakes read as inconsistencies rather than obvious texture problems, and with the west-facing window walls common in this neighborhood, late afternoon sun rakes across the surface and exposes every uneven patch.
How should you prep an orange peel wall before painting?
Prep means patching damage with texture-matched compound, sanding only the high points if needed, and priming evenly before topcoat. Skipping any of these is where most DIY jobs on these tall feature walls go wrong.
Patch and match the texture first
Old anchor holes or TV mount damage need texture applied before any paint goes on. We see this constantly in resale Flying Horse homes: a previous owner sanded a patch smooth and painted over it, and it stays invisible until afternoon sun hits it at an angle across the wall. Matching orange peel by hand with a rattle-can texture product is hard to get right across these large wall spans, and a $15 can of texture spray can cost more in redo time than having it done correctly the first time.
Don’t oversand, and always prime
Light sanding to knock down drips is fine, but aggressive sanding flattens texture unevenly, and the raking light from Flying Horse’s large window walls will find that inconsistency. Skipping primer is another common shortcut. Orange peel has more surface area than flat drywall, so it absorbs paint unevenly, especially over the darker builder-grade tans common in original interiors here. Without primer you get blotchy “flashing” that extra topcoat won’t fix.
What’s the right technique for painting orange peel?
The right technique is back-rolling with a thicker nap roller after cutting in, applying paint in a W or M pattern, and avoiding thin, fast coats. On the two-story walls and stairwells common here, this usually means proper extension poles or scaffolding rather than stretching from a ladder, both for finish quality and safety.
Roller nap, coats, and cutting in
A 3/8″ nap roller is standard for the light to medium orange peel found in most Flying Horse homes. Too short a nap won’t push paint into the texture’s valleys; too long can overload it and cause buildup, especially on the soft, light wall colors popular right now. Two full coats is the standard, not a one-coat touch-up. A single thin coat will streak across an open-concept sightline that runs from the kitchen to the fireplace. Edges, trim, and stair stringers should always be cut in with a brush first, since the texture near trim is denser and blends better with brush work than a roller edge.
What actually happens on real jobs in this neighborhood?
The texture itself is rarely the hard part. The hard part is color under these homes’ light. A soft greige that looks great on a chip can read blue or purple in a north-facing great room with orange peel texture, because the texture’s shadows interact with cool tones differently than flat walls do. We always test a sample directly on the textured wall, not a painted board, since both the texture and the mountain light change how color reads through the day.
We also see “just freshen up the builder color” jobs turn into bigger projects once we start prepping. Homes from Flying Horse’s earlier phases are now 15 to 20 years old, and original texture sometimes has paint layers starting to separate slightly at the peaks, invisible until fresh paint pulls at it. That’s why a flat per-room quote without an in-person walkthrough is often inaccurate.
What mistakes do homeowners make most often?
- Skipping the test patch on the great room wall, then committing to color across the whole open floor plan.
- Using flat sheen near stairs and hallways, where it scuffs easily. Eggshell or matte holds up better in high-traffic homes.
- Buying cheap roller covers that shed lint into wet paint, which is far more visible on a 20-foot wall than a small one.
- Ignoring the elevation and dry climate. Flying Horse sits high and dry, so paint can flash-dry faster than the can suggests, causing lap marks on long walls if you don’t work in small sections.
- Trying to smooth texture out with paint alone. Paint doesn’t fill texture; that requires a skim coat or re-texture project instead.
When is painting over orange peel a good fit, and when isn’t it?
It’s a great fit if your walls are structurally sound and you want to move past a dated builder color, refresh a sheen, or prep for a sale. It’s also a smart, cost-effective option if the texture itself doesn’t bother you.
It is not a good fit if you actually dislike the texture and want the smoother, modern finish seen in some newer construction nearby. Painting over it won’t solve that; you’d need a skim coat or texture removal first. We’d rather tell you that now than sell a paint job that won’t give you what you want. It’s also not a great DIY candidate on tall great room and stairwell walls, where working at height and matching texture across large spans is where projects usually go sideways.
What does it cost to paint orange peel texture in Flying Horse?
Cost depends on square footage, ceiling height, number of coats, sheen, and how much patch or texture-matching work is needed. Flying Horse homes tend to run larger than average for Colorado Springs, with taller ceilings and more wall area per room, which affects labor compared to a smaller home elsewhere in the city. We walk every space in person before quoting, because texture condition and ceiling height change the labor, and we’d rather give you an accurate number than a generic estimate that shifts once we’re on site.
If you’re in Flying Horse contact us for a clear, no-surprises quote on your orange peel walls, whether that’s one great room or your whole home’s interior, reach out here and we’ll come take a look.
Simplify Painting | Colorado Springs, CO | simplifypainting.com
Licensed, insured, and local.
